| Year | Nelson Broach Memorial Champions | Year | Nelson Broach Senior Champions |
| 2008 | Brock Kelley – Tim Kelley (62) | ||
| 2009 | Jay Livingston – Van Williams (139) | ||
| 2010 | Tony Good – Tim Kelley (71) | ||
| 2011 | Rich Jeremiah – Ben Keefer (135) | ||
| 2012 | DJ Dougherty – John Reynolds (135) | ||
| 2013 | Rich Jeremiah – Ben Keefer (131) | ||
| 2014 | Rich Jeremiah – Ben Keefer (68) | 2014 | Leon Roday – Phil White (67) |
| 2015 | Steve Serrao – Alex Sleeker (137) | 2015 | Leon Roday – Phil White (137) |
| 2016 | Ted Dougherty – Larry Loving Jr (102) | 2016 | Jim Hudson – Scott Reisenweaver (102) |
| 2017 | Ken Cocolin – Ryan Taylor (64) | 2017 | Gary Cicatiello – David Jordan (65) |
| 2018 | Matt Farrell – Kevin South (68) | 2018 | Mark Alonzi – Gary Cicatiello (71) |
| 2019 | Rich Jeremiah --Ben Keefer (67) | 2019 | David Partridge--Hank Klein (68) |
| 2020 | Larry Loving-Steve Jenkins (63) | 2020 | Greg Bales-Scott Gordon (67) |
| 2021 | Steve Serrao – Alex Sleeker (68) | 2021 | Greg Bales-Scott Gordon (65) |
| 2022 | Ben Boyer-Tim Dickson (65) | 2022 | Scott Bemberis-Ed Riley (68) |
| 2023 | Spence Andrews-Brock Kelley (62) | 2023 | Scott Bemberis-Ed Riley (69) |
| 2024 | Marco Poccia-Ryan Taylor (65) | 2024 | Steve Firkins-Kevin South (69) |
| 2025 | Michael Joyce-John Rosenstock (65) | 2025 | Ray Dingledine-Kevin Williamson (69) |
