| Year | Regular POY | Senior POY |
| 2014 | Ben Keefer | Leon Roday |
| 2015 | Scott Reisenweaver | Leon Roday |
| 2016 | Steve Serrao | Rusty Breeden |
| 2017 | Steve Serrao | Greg Marbold |
| 2018 | Tom Vlahakis | Scott Reisenweaver |
| 2019 | Ben Keefer | David Jordan |
| 2020 | John Rosenstock | Scott Reisenweaver |
| 2021 | Steve Serrao | Steve Serrao |
| 2022 | Jordan Utley | Paras Pandya |
| 2023 | Steve Serrao | Paras Pandya |
| 2024 | Brandon Ramsuer | Kevin South |
| 2025 | Brandon Ramsuer | Steve Serrao |
